April 27th, 2009 (11:04 am)
Adultfanfiction.net makes me angry.
I've generally stopped haunting those grounds, as they tend to produce nothing but zombies as opposed to friendly ghosts. I've read a lot of good, quality male/male stories (unfortunately older stories) and a couple of decent male/female stories. But the female/female stories. They make me tear my hair out and scream obscenities.
Yuri makes me want to bash my head across the wall on several levels. First of all, and less importantly for once in my book, they are horribly written. There's no plot, no character development, no differentiation between you're and your, etc. They're bad. I can handle bad writing, though. I can take in stride the fact that some people, try as they might, cannot write. I can even forgive that. It's what this plotless, underdeveloped pornography is about thematically that irritates me.
Two categories of yuri porn seem to exist 1) Sexually experienced older girl makes younger girl realize that, yeah, she likes it when the older girl's tongue licks her anatomically incorrectly-placed clit and 2) Sexually mature older girl degrades sexual immature younger girl physically, psychologicically, emotionally, and sexual only to have younger girl LOVE the abuse. Now, I realize that het and yaoi exist with the same basic plotline, subsituting older girl for older boy. However, the bandwagon effect doesn't justify the overarching themes of control and degredation that run rampant. The older woman in yuri is just the replacement for the older man found in het and yaoi. She's female physically (her perky breasts are mentioned more than enough times), but the situation is consistently reminescent of the classic case scenario of a girl losing her innocence to the boy who knows things. Because it's quite alright for men to know about sex, but it would be better if women stayed in the dark until that perfect man, or perfect Temari, comes along and opens her little virgin eyes.
She fights it, at first. She blushes deep shades of red, ashamed of what she's doing but unable to stop the way she's getting wet. She's knows this shouldn't be happening at all, much less enjoying it, wanting to give up the fight and let it happen. Still blushing, stuttering, and moaning at too-high decibles, she lets the older girl have her wicked way with her.
Read that again, substituting older girl for older boy, and perhaps you'll see what I mean.
I'm not saying that lesbians, or in this case straight girls experimenting with hidden lesbian tendencies, don't ever have sex in such a manner. They may. My problem is with the blatant superimposition of heterosexual gender normatives upon homosexual sex. I'm not going to go into great length on this one, but if clarification is needed, see
sub_textual and her post on Gender, Feminism, and Naruto. She is far more academic about it than I am being. However, I will borrow a leaf out of her book, when I decry the fact that taught both genders, male and female, to construct their identity through heterosexuality and the male dominance that is inherent in that construction. The majority of yuri writers are boys, and they perceive this lesbian sex they are writing through their lense of male privilege that is granted by societal constructions of male roles. While yes, this certainly explains a lot, in no way does it excuse it. Fics like Let's Get Naked, More Womanly Now, Naruto's Naughty Nurses, Bitches in Heat, Temari and Her Toys, Horny Hokage, Having a Little Fun with Sakura, Hello Nurse, and Diaper Camp serve to remind me just how far women's liberation has yet to go. Boys are still beig taught that their sexuality is based on their male privilege, ostensibly encouraging them to to view as sexy the control and degradation of the female. They are writing about it in fics like Bitches in Heat, allowing it to circulate uninhibited.
And women are doing nothing to stop it. Because as demonstrated by the same approximate problem in many yaoi and het fics, women too believe that their sexual identity and experience ought to be constructed around the male.
I need to write some yuri or something. Maybe I'll feel better then.